Actress Donna Mills, 85, claims Playboy yanked her from a planned magazine cover after she refused to undress during a three-day photo shoot, and decades later, she's releasing those never-before-seen images on her own terms through OnlyFans.
Mills, best known for playing the scheming Abby Cunningham on the CBS primetime soap "Knots Landing" from 1980 to 1989, told Fox News Digital she agreed to the Playboy shoot on one condition: she would not show anything. Playboy accepted the deal. Then the cameras started rolling, and the pressure began.
The photographer, Mills said, spent three days nudging her to reveal more. His go-to line, she recalled, was simple and relentless: "Move that sheet down a little bit." Mills did not budge. She brought her own reinforcements, her publicist and her hairdresser, and stationed them on set to make sure nothing slipped.
The result, by Mills' account, was a set of striking images in which she never actually bared anything. And that, she says, is exactly why Playboy shelved her.
Mills put it bluntly in the interview:
"I was supposed to be on the cover, and they didn't put me on the cover because I didn't show anything. And that p***ed me off."
She had walked in with clear terms. She walked out with photos she liked and a cover she never got. Playboy has not publicly responded to Mills' version of events.
The episode sat with her for years. Mills described the photos as tasteful but unmistakably bold. "They're very sexy," she said. But without the cover, those images never reached the audience they were shot for, until now.
Mills admitted she had no idea what OnlyFans was when the platform's representatives first approached her. "I didn't know what OnlyFans was. I'd never heard of it," she said. She knew the platform's reputation, she described it as "kind of an adult site", and that gave her pause.
But the pitch won her over. Mills said the OnlyFans team assured her she could set her own boundaries entirely. She paraphrased their message this way:
"You do what you're comfortable with. You don't have to do nakedness. You can, if you want to, you can. If you don't want to, you don't have to."
That promise, control without compromise, was the opposite of what she experienced on the Playboy set decades earlier. Mills said the OnlyFans representatives "couldn't have been nicer and couldn't have been more accommodating."
The platform has become a surprisingly broad tent in recent years. Mills herself has insisted her page is not what people might assume, and she is far from the only celebrity to use the site for content that falls well outside its original adult-entertainment niche.
Before signing on, Mills consulted the two people whose opinions mattered most: her daughter and her spouse. Both gave her the green light.
Her daughter's reaction was enthusiastic and immediate. "Go, mom! Come on, go," Mills recalled her saying. Mills added that her daughter trusted she "wasn't going to do anything embarrassing." Her spouse was equally direct: "I trust you. You do what you want to do."
With that family support, Mills launched her OnlyFans account and announced plans to share the never-before-seen Playboy shoot photos there, images that have sat unseen for years because she refused to meet someone else's terms.
Mills framed the move as part of a broader shift she began thinking about a few years ago, when she asked herself what she wanted the next chapter of her life to look like. The answer, she said, was to become an inspiration, particularly for women.
"I'd like to show people, and particularly women, that it doesn't have to be over. It's just a new chapter. It's not the end... It's just something you can enjoy. You should enjoy. It's part of your life."
She described her planned OnlyFans content as "spicy", a word she said has always defined her brand. "I think what the page will be, will be spicy. That's kind of always been my thing, to be a little spicy," she said. Beyond photos, she plans to use the platform's video and messaging features to communicate directly with fans she credits for sustaining her career.
Other celebrities have found the platform useful for reasons that have nothing to do with its original reputation. Sami Sheen has credited her OnlyFans income with funding a beach house, showing the platform's earning power for public figures willing to build a subscriber base.
Mills also channeled her most famous role when asked what Abby Cunningham would think of the move. "Are you kidding? Abby would be all for it," she said. "She was for anything that was going to move her forward, that was going to be to her advantage. So, she would be dead on for this. She would love this."
Mills said she sees the OnlyFans launch as a chance to connect with the audience that made her career, on her schedule, by her rules, with no photographer asking her to move the sheet down. "At my age, it's like a whole new life is opening up," she said.
Playboy told her no because she wouldn't compromise. Decades later, she found a platform that said yes precisely because she didn't have to. That's a lesson worth more than any magazine cover.